St. Croix 360

River stories to inspire stewardship.

  • Share News
  • Event Calendar
  • About
    • Contact
    • Subscribe
  • Support

Prosecution moves forward on St. Croix River sand mine spill

The Wisconsin DNR has forwarded the case to the state's attorney general over the April dam failure which sent sand spilling into the river for five days.

By Greg Seitz | June 14, 2012 | 4 minute read

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Telegram
A stream flowing into the St. Croix River near Grantsburg runs brown with sediment from a silica (frac) sand mine

Photo taken in April by the hiker who alerted the DNR about the spill.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources announced last Friday that it had forwarded the case of a sand mine which spilled fine sediments into the St. Croix River to the state’s attorney general for prosecution.

St. Croix River sand mine spill

Site where containment berm failed

A containment berm constructed at the mine near Grantsburg to hold water in a settling pond is believed to have burst in April, causing soupy water to flow down a stream, through a wetland, and into the river just below the Highway 70 bridge. The pollution continued for five days until a hiker noticed it and notified authorities.

The DNR alleges the company violated the law in three ways: discharging water from the mine site without a permit, failing to maintain the containment berm which failed, and not notifying the DNR when it built the new settling pond which leaked into the river.

The Star Tribune reports:

For five days, massive amounts of ultra-fine sand and water flowed from a pond through an inadequate berm that was formed to contain it and into an environmentally sensitive area that included a wetland, creek and the federally protected St. Croix River. A hiker discovered the cream-colored spill as it flowed through the creek into the river.

Company officials did not immediately return phone calls Monday. But the Wisconsin DNR said the operators are working to fix the problem and, earlier, a company spokesperson said the company regretted the incident.

Dix said an investigation into the damage is underway. But a sand spill of that size could destroy a wetland and smother fragile fish spawning grounds and mussel beds in the river, environmental officials said.

“They used on-site soils that were too fine to maintain a tight seal” in the berm, Dix said.

Continue reading …

Department of Natural Resources spokeswoman Deb Dix told Minnesota Public Radio News, “They did not construct properly, were not out there on a daily basis to watch what’s going on, and with their permit conditions they should have an understanding of what they need to do so that we don’t need to be out there every day.”

Mussels and fish

One of the primary concerns from the incident is its possible impact on rare mussels that live in the St. Croix River, as well as on fish.

The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources provided the map below from its rare species database. It shows where surveys have found one of several aquatic species that are either rare, endangered, or of special concern.

Click to view larger. As mentioned above, the sand spilled into the river just below the Highway 70 bridge, which is visible on the map.

The blue dots on the map represent vertebrae species, such as fish, which could include gilt darter, southern brook lamprey, and lake sturgeon.

The orange dots are survey sites where mussels have been found — each dot represents a site where up to seven different species have been found. Mussels include:

Elliptio dilatata

Elliptio dilatata, photo by Darby Creek Association

  • Elliptio dilatata (spike) – Special Concern
  • Ligumia recta (black sandshell) – Special Concern
  • Cyclonaias tuberculata (purple wartyback) – Threatened
  • Actinonaias ligamentina (mucket) – Threatened
  • Cumberlandia monodonta (spectacle case) – Listed as Endangered in Wisconsin
  • Lasmigona costata (fluted shell) – Special Concern
  • Pleurobema coccineum (round pigtoe) – Threatened
  • Obovaria olivaria (hickory nut) – Special concern
  • Alasmidonta marginata (elktoe) – Threatened
All species of mussels are protected by law, and it is illegal to take dead mussel shells from the St. Croix River.

Potential penalties

St. Croix River sand mine spill

Mine site (Wisconsin DNR photo)

In a letter to the mining companies, the DNR described several violations of Wisconsin laws.

The letter mentions two Wisconsin statutes, one of which carries maximum fines of $5,000 per day of violation, another which would mean fines of at most $10,000 per day. Both have minimum fines of just $10 per day.

Ultimately, the maximum fine possible for this incident is apparently $50,000. One of the statutes also has the potential for up to six months of jail time.

There has not been any news about possible federal charges for harming the federally-protected Wild & Scenic River.

Related

Trackbacks

  1. Wisconsin's sand county odyssey, part 2: what follows y | Climate Chronicle says:
    June 25, 2012 at 5:37 pm

    […] frequent and more intense in recent decades, occur. Just such an overflow occurred in May, fouling the St. Croix River, a federally designated Wild & Scenic River in its upper […]

Follow

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

St. Croix 360 is 100% supported by readers.

Click here to contribute →

 

Latest stories

  • No wakes allowed on lower St. Croix due to high water
  • Snake River Canoe Race sees fast times and smooth paddling
  • Developer proposes 12 new ‘cabins’ on St. Croix River

More news

  • Residents resist St. Croix Falls riverside development proposal
  • Birds, Bugs, and Blooms: A St. Croix 360 spring Saturday
  • Tribal officials applaud plan to change derogatory names for places
  • Stillwater teen drowns in St. Croix River while helping save friend
  • Afton State Park phenology May 13 to 19, 2022
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

About

St. Croix 360 builds support for river stewardship, and connects people and organizations. It is an independent news source produced by Greg Seitz, with past support from the St. Croix River Association.

Donate to St. Croix 360 today »

Story of 360

One of the biggest challenges facing the St. Croix River is harmful blooms of algae in in the lower river, due to excess nutrients in runoff. The goal is to restore the river by reducing phosphorus levels to 360 tons/year. Learn more »

Share Your News

St. Croix 360 is powered by a broad community of St. Croix River-loving people. Please visit our submission page to send tips, press releases, and other news.

Submit an Event

Lower St. Croix: St. Croix 360 partners with online calendar St. Croix Splash.

  • Submit your events to Splash.
  • Share it with St. Croix 360 for promotion.

For events elsewhere in the watershed, contact St. Croix 360 directly.

St. Croix 360 Syndication

To help increase awareness of the St. Croix River, news organizations and other outlets are free to share St. Croix 360 content, as long as you follow a few simple rules.

Republish St. Croix 360 stories »

Partners

  • St. Croix River Association
  • St. Croix Watershed Research Station
  • ArtReach St. Croix
  • You and all St. Croix 360's readers!
Handcrafted in May Township, Minnesota. Please contribute today »
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
 

Loading Comments...