Looking for long lost prairie remnants in Afton State Park

Bluff prairies were once ignored by humans and home to unique wildlife, but may now need help to survive.

By

/

/

7 minute read

Two hundred years ago, high up on two large bluffs within what’s now Afton State Park, were strips of prairie that differed from Minnesota’s once vast tallgrass prairies, in that they occurred exclusively on steep, rocky, south-facing slopes along stream valleys.

These prairies and many others of its type in the region escaped being cultivated in the late 19th century, and since then have escaped development, left to be eaten up by the surrounding forests.

Local geography

Though mainly occurring in the Upper Mississippi River Valley, occurrences of bluff prairies extended north into the lower St. Croix River Valley of Washington County, particularly onto a landform known as the Cottage Grove plain. The plain was spared from glacial sediments during the late Wisconsin glaciation, instead left to be eroded by wind and water, leaving the terrain dissected and rolling.

The soil on the surface is thin and underlain by thick layers of bedrock that are exposed along stream valleys and glacial meltwater drainage channels. Bluff prairies also occurred on the adjacent river terraces.

The southern half of Washington County; red represents the Cottage Grove Plain and yellow represents the St. Croix River Terraces.

Prior to European-American settlement in the early 1800s, bluff prairies were extensive across southern Washington County, and they had mostly escaped agriculture on a major scale until new designs in plows were introduced during the King Wheat era of the 1860s to the 1880s (City of Cottage Grove, 1986).

Today, bluff prairies are restricted to scattered slopes and bluffs too steep and rocky to plow and cultivate.

Bluff prairies are specialized ecosystems

Despite the unforgiving soil conditions and persistent sunlight throughout the year, healthy bluff prairies are lush with grasses and forbs and offer spectacular displays of blooming flowers throughout the growing season.

Pasque-flower, prairie violet, and puccoons are the first prairie plants to emerge in the spring, followed by tiny prairie blue-eyed grass and the bright orange blooms of butterfly-weed appearing in June. The late summer months are a profusion of vibrant colors, a grand finale of the season—asters, goldenrods, blazing stars, and prairie clovers, just to name a few.

Lithospermum incisum (fringed puccoon), Lost Valley Prairie SNA (Photo by Michael Lynch, May 30, 2014)

Though the vegetation composition is similar to that of typical upland prairies, forbs such as downy paintbrush, ground-plum, and cylindric blazing star are characteristic of these bluff prairies and otherwise limited or absent from the region.

Bluff prairies of the region also offered ideal breeding habitat for eastern kingbirds, eastern meadowlarks, field sparrows, and American goldfinches. Larger rocks provided both shelter and basking spots for prairie skinks and garter snakes.

The Afton bluff prairies

Before Euro-American settlers suppressed the recurring fires that upland prairies of the region needed to avoid being overgrown by forests. The really dry soils and abundant prairie sod of the Afton bluff prairies would have acted as a giant tinderbox. With these much-needed fires eliminated from the equation entirely, a native species of juniper called eastern red cedar has proved to be a problem in many of Minnesota’s fire-starved prairies, the bluff prairies within Afton State Park especially.

Unlike the bluff prairies of Lost Valley Scientific Natural Area south of Afton that are well-known by botanists and maintained by DNR staff and volunteers, the largely hidden and difficult to reach bluff prairies on the St. Croix river terraces have been forgotten over time and most of them are now overgrown with red cedar. Some of these prairies lack prairie vegetation to some degree and would no longer be considered a prairie.

Top, left to right: Historical aerial photographs taken of the future state park in 1938 and 1964 show the progression of encroaching red cedars and hardwoods into the bluff prairies. Yellow polygons represent a general estimation of where the Afton bluff prairies were located at those times. Notice the homestead in the far left of both photographs. Bottom left: Screenshot from Natural Communities and Rare Species of Washington County, Minnesota 1987-1989. Bottom right: Aerial photograph from 2015.

Plant specimens submitted to the Bell Museum herbarium records by Gerald Ownbey, late botanist and professor emeritus at the University of Minnesota, indicated that the Afton bluff prairies contained rich prairie vegetation as recently as the late 1980s. A map of Washington County’s biological communities in 1987 through 1989 indicates that the bluff prairies still contained prairie vegetation, but they had already become severely fragmented into small openings, separated by dense patches of red cedar.

I was optimistic that the prairies might still be there, and intrigued that there were prairies on such steep ground, hiding in a park that I’d been visiting since I was a kid with my grandparents. I then decided to go on an adventure late summer of 2019 to relocate the bluff prairies myself to see what has changed over time.

My experience

I’d seen bluff prairies in southeastern Minnesota in the past that contained prairie vegetation despite having abundant red cedar, so a part of me was optimistic that the prairie vegetation of the Afton bluff prairies were going to be relatively intact.

When I first arrived at the park and turned my attention to the south bluff prairies, I hadn’t studied the park’s trail map very well and ended up neglecting to use the trail that conveniently went up and over the west side of the bluff, instead going up the east slope, which was unexpectedly overgrown with buckthorn and muddy. In hindsight, I could’ve hiked the other trail and easily avoided bushwhacking, not to mention picking up dozens of ticks!

I finally arrived at the top of the bluff after what seemed like hours, and it didn’t take long to locate the openings once I was there. It also didn’t take long, however, to notice the dense treeline of red cedar that lined the south side of the bluff—where the prairie was, according to the maps I’d had pulled on my phone.

I was relieved when I spotted a large enough opening in the canopy through a wide deer trail to be a prairie. Looking straight forward, you see that you’re above Afton Alps Ski Resort. Looking straight down, you see a steep drop with chunks of lichen-covered bedrock barely peeking out of the bluff, a thin carpet of prairie sod forming the matrix in between. Exploring was treacherous, to say the least, but this is just what I wanted to see.

The main bluff prairie opening on the south bluff. Despite remaining fairly open, prairie forbs are nearly absent and grasses indicative of disturbance (particularly panic grasses, Dichanthelium spp.) are common.

Next course of action was to check out the vegetation.

Except for a small, yellow-flowered plant called hoary frostweed and a smattering of prairie grasses, signs of any other native forbs were absent, and many non-native species such as mullein, black medic, Queen Anne’s lace, thistles, sweet-clovers, and crown vetch had established into the thin soil. After a half hour search, it became clear I wasn’t going to find anything, so I continued north to the north bluff.

As a trail is located directly below the north bluff’s prairie openings, getting to them was much easier. Unfortunately, these prairies appeared to be in worse condition. Between each of the three or four scattered openings, red cedar had joined forces with buckthorn, forming nearly impenetrable forests with an understory largely devoid of growth besides new buckthorn. More bushwhacking ensued to reach these openings. These prairie openings were much more open and from a distance appeared to be undisturbed, until making the realization that the vegetation was similar to the south bluff prairie—native grasses and invasive plants predominant, native forbs absent.

This photo shows the largest prairie opening on the north bluff, taken in August, 2019.  Although some plants may have already “melted” back into the soil for the season, there are signs of native forbs present, with potential for blooming or fruiting.

What caused these disturbances in the prairies is currently unclear, to me at least, though a likely explanation is grazing. Perhaps cattle that were allowed to roam freely on pastures above the bluff prairies strayed down the slopes to graze on the prairie vegetation. The cattle would have trampled and disturbed the soil in the process, making it easier for red cedar and other invasive plants to establish and spread.

Restoration

Overall, I believe that the bluff prairies of Afton State Park have good restoration potential. Invasive plants and woody vegetation should be dealt with and native biodiversity should be reintroduced over time. This could include spreading prairie grass seeds already present on the prairies and re-introducing historical species such as ground plum, cylindric blazing star, purple prairie clover, sky-blue aster, and prairie dropseed. To help ensure future restoration, interpretive signs could be added to explain the sensitive restoration project, as well as its history.

1 inch = 1,150 ft

I think that having the bluff prairies (yellow) restored would not only benefit the ecosystem and provide breeding habitat for a number of birds, mammals, and reptiles, but (with great caution and respect for the prairies) would also benefit students, photographers, or just nature lovers in general, because they would learn about restoration efforts and have just a few more native prairies to see and enjoy.


Jaxon Lane is a college student, photographer, and lifelong nature enthusiast currently living in White Bear Lake, Minnesota. He is most interested in ecology, botany, and herpetology, and spends his free time in nature hiking and photographing wildlife and plant life. When not studying or out in nature, he also plays music and makes nature art.

References

Almendinger, J. C., Minnesota Biological Survey. (1990). Natural Communities and Rare Species of Washington County 1987-1989. Minnesota Biological Survey.

Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. (1979). A Management Plan for Afton State Park. Retrieved from the Minnesota Legislative Reference Library. https://www.leg.state.mn.us/docs/pre2003/other/811348.pdf.

Wovcha, D. S., Delaney, B. C., & Nordquist, G. E. (1995). Minnesota’s St. Croix River Valley and Anoka Sandplain: A Guide to Native Habitats. University of Minnesota Press.

Hobbs, H. C. & Goebel, J. E. (1982). S-01 Geologic map of Minnesota, Quaternary geology. Minnesota Geological Survey. Retrieved from the University of Minnesota Digital Conservancy, http://hdl.handle.net/11299/60085.


Comments

St. Croix 360 offers commenting to support productive discussion. We don’t allow name-calling, personal attacks, or misinformation. This discussion may be heavily moderated and we reserve the right to block nonconstructive comments. Please: Be kind, give others the benefit of the doubt, read the article closely, check your assumptions, and stay curious. Thank you!

“Opinion is really the lowest form of human knowledge. It requires no accountability, no understanding. The highest form of knowledge is empathy, for it requires us to suspend our egos and live in another’s world.” – Bill Bullard

5 responses to “Looking for long lost prairie remnants in Afton State Park”

  1. Linda Avatar
    Linda

    Wow. Nice work Jax. Very interesting and informative.

  2. Steve Quick Avatar
    Steve Quick

    Someone you might want to contact is Jason Husveth, who seeks for rare native plant species throughout Minnesota. He’s frequently at Afton State park and I know he’s found some odd plants there (walking ferns, as I recall). Critical Connections Ecological Services, Inc. is his business.

  3. Kate Seitz Avatar
    Kate Seitz

    Great article! I had no idea there were bluff prairies. Thanks!

  4. John Leinen Avatar

    Are these also called, “goat prairies”? I was a volunteer at the park when the volunteer group was first formed. At that time the park manager showed me what he called a goat prairie. It was along the trail, on the north side of Trout Brook, that goes down the slope, from the western most point of the trail that circles the old farm fields, to the bottom land along the brook. There were still pasque flower growing there, back in the late eighties.

  5. […] Most of the land surrounding Afton State Park was bluff prairie. Eventually, white colonists came along and started to use the land for agriculture, decimating the prairies. They also worked to eliminate wildfires – which are vital to the prairie’s survival – and as a result, native trees are gradually growing where the prairies once existed. The State is engaging in ongoing prairie restoration efforts at the park. Curious as to their efforts, I walked on a trail that loops around the restored prairie, which also has interpretive displays that explains the restoration process. […]

REPUBLISHING TERMS

You may republish this article online or in print under our Creative Commons license. You may not edit or shorten the text, you must attribute the article to St. Croix 360 and you must include the author’s name in your republication.

If you have any questions, please email greg@stcroix360.com

License

Creative Commons License Attribution-ShareAlikeCreative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike
Looking for long lost prairie remnants in Afton State Park