St. Croix 360

River stories to inspire stewardship.

  • Share News
  • Event Calendar
  • About
    • Contact
    • Subscribe
  • Support

Minnesota agency says Line 3 oil pipeline unnecessary

New pipeline would cross under St. Croix tributaries, but Department of Commerce says the company can't demonstrate it is needed for energy supply.

By Greg Seitz | September 12, 2017 | 2 minute read

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Telegram

Enbridge map showing preferred route of Line 3 replacement crossing the upper Kettle River in Carlton County. Click here for a PDF map.

The Canadian company proposing a large oil pipeline across northern Minnesota has not proven to the state’s government that there is a need for more oil transportation, the Department of Commerce stated this week.

Enbridge’s Line 3 replacement project would reroute an old existing pipeline so it could carry double the amount of oil — up to 35 million gallons per day if approved.

The proposed route would include crossings of the Kettle River and other tributary streams of the St. Croix River.

But, according to expert testimony submitted to the Public Utilities Commission, Enbridge has failed to meet legal requirements to show why the pipeline would be in the public’s interest.

Relying on outside individuals with expertise in economics and oil markets, the agency found that Minnesota’s refineries are not suffering from a lack of supply, and demand is not expected to increase in the foreseeable future.

The new pipeline would cross numerous “high quality” water resources, especially in the stretch including the St. Croix watershed, raising the stakes of a possible rupture and spill.

“It remains to be seen whether the long-term impacts on land and water resources that would be impacted by a spill would be sufficiently remediated,” Kate O’Connell, Manager of Energy Regulation and Planning for the Minnesota Department of Commerce, testified. “The number of water crossings from the Applicant’s preferred route and other route alternatives would exacerbate such concerns. Such concerns appear to be higher on the Clearbrook-to-Superior segment than on the Neche-to-Clearbrook segment.”

Meanwhile, the existing pipeline Enbridge proposes to replace also poses numerous risks to Minnesota’s environment, with “limited benefits” to Minnesota refineries.

“Minnesota would be better off if Enbridge proposed to cease operations of the existing Line 3, without any new pipeline being built,” O’Connell said.

Enbridge disagreed with the Department of Commerce, promising to respond.

“The Department of Commerce (DOC) opinion is only one view, which we and other energy consumers will respond to in detail,” Enbridge said, according to Reuters. “We disagree … as do other shippers and consumers of oil in Minnesota and the U.S. Midwest, as outlined in other testimony filed today substantiating the need for the project.”

Enbridge says the pipeline is an essential component of its Mainline System, which carries oil from sources in North Dakota and Canada to refineries in the Chicago area. The system also includes Line 61, a large pipeline transporting crude oil through the St. Croix headwaters in Wisconsin.

The Public Utilities Commission expects to make a decision on the project by next spring.

Submit comments

The Public Utilities Commission is currently accepting comments, and has several hearings scheduled in the next two months.

Deadline: Wednesday, November 22, 2017, at 4:30 p.m.
Email: publicadvisor.puc@state.mn.us
Online: mn.gov/puc/line3/participate/comment
U.S. Mail:
Scott Ek
Minnesota Public Utilities Commission
121 7th Place East, Suite 350
St. Paul, MN 55101
Fax: 651-297-7073

Please include the Commission’s Docket Numbers 14-916 (Certificate of Need) or 15-137 (Route) and OAH Docket Numbers 65-2500-32764 (Certificate of Need) or 65-2500-33377 (Route) in the subject line of all communications.

Conservation news on St. Croix 360 is supported by the St. Croix River Association, which works to protect, restore and celebrate the St. Croix River and its watershed.

Related articles:

Follow

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Features

Healthy headwaters: Upper St. Croix tributaries are mostly pristine — and need protection

Replacing damaged dam will restore fish habitat and a popular lake

Starstruck: Communities seek to keep night skies dark above the St. Croix River

St. Croix 360 is now 100% supported by readers.

Click here to contribute →

 

Latest News

County asks for feedback on plans for new park on river north of Hudson

Cities can help migrating birds on their way by planting more trees and turning lights off at night

Minnesota DNR seeks input on potential waterfowl hunting changes

Speakers will discuss racial justice topics in St. Croix Valley

New St. Croix River boat ramp to open next year

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

About

St. Croix 360 builds support for river stewardship, and connects people and organizations. It is an independent news source produced by Greg Seitz, with past support from the St. Croix River Association.

Donate to St. Croix 360 today »

Story of 360

One of the biggest challenges facing the St. Croix River is harmful blooms of algae in in the lower river, due to excess nutrients in runoff. The goal is to restore the river by reducing phosphorus levels to 360 tons/year. Learn more »

Share Your News

St. Croix 360 is powered by a broad community of St. Croix River-loving people. Please visit our submission page to send tips, press releases, and other news.

Submit an Event

Lower St. Croix: St. Croix 360 partners with online calendar St. Croix Splash.

  • Submit your events to Splash.
  • Share it with St. Croix 360 for promotion.

For events elsewhere in the watershed, contact St. Croix 360 directly.

St. Croix 360 Syndication

To help increase awareness of the St. Croix River, news organizations and other outlets are free to share St. Croix 360 content, as long as you follow a few simple rules.

Republish St. Croix 360 stories »

Partners

  • St. Croix River Association
  • St. Croix Watershed Research Station
  • ArtReach St. Croix
  • You and all St. Croix 360's readers!
Handcrafted in May Township, Minnesota. Please contribute today »
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.